Is It Time to Talk to Hamas?
By Jonathan Kuttab
Last week, I lamented the failure of the world to address the siege of Gaza, which has gone on for 15 years and kept two million Palestinians trapped in an unlivable open-air prison. The real elephant in the room, however, and the justification used for failing to lift that siege is the fact that the Gaza Strip is currently ruled by Hamas—considered an illegitimate terrorist organization, hell-bent on the destruction of Israel and, as such, not a potential candidate for negotiations or peace.
The existence of Hamas is also the lame excuse given for the paralysis of peace talks. Since the Palestinians are divided and Mahmoud Abbas cannot (and is not allowed to) talk either with or for Hamas, it is said that there exists “no one to talk to” on the Palestinian side. Hamas has become a convenient excuse for indefinite occupation.
It may well be time to broach the taboo subject of talking to Hamas and seek instead a way of bringing them into the peace conversation. Certainly, there can be no peace without Hamas and its followers participating in some way or another.
Now, I must begin by saying that I am neither an apologist nor do I in any way speak for Hamas. In fact, I reject their political philosophy, and I believe they have failed the people of Gaza in many ways. Yet, the isolation, demonization, and exclusion of Hamas from the political process has not been helpful.
The situation for Hamas is in many respects analogous to the situation of the PLO before the famous handshake that took place on the White House lawn. The PLO, too, was considered a terrorist organization; its charter was unacceptable, and some of its tactics were abhorrent. Yet, it represented at the time the Palestinian people, and one makes peace with one’s enemies, not with one’s friends.
In addition, the PLO carried out many civilian functions and played an important part in the lives of the people. Its demonization was a convenient way of demonizing all Palestinian people and preventing any progress towards reconciliation.
Brave individuals, including Christians, challenged “conventional wisdom” and at great risk to themselves, their reputation, and their careers were willing to meet with PLO officials, even though doing so was against the law at the time. Andrew Young (a former pastor and associate of Dr. King) was the US representative to the UN when he lost his job and damaged his career after meeting with the PLO representative to the UN, the late Zuhdi Tarazi.
Quaker and other church officials met with Yasser Arafat, even advising and urging him to take the necessary steps to move towards negotiations. This included changing the charter of the PLO, making public statements in favor of the recognition of Israel, and abandoning armed struggle.
Is it time to do the same with Hamas? After all, they do have physical control of the Gaza Strip’s interior and enjoy the support of a sizable portion of the Palestinian population—many of whom voted for Hamas only because they were frustrated with the corruption and inefficiency of Fatah and the Palestinain Authority.
Some may argue that Hamas is an evil entity and that they have no interest in making peace, that it is a waste of time and effort to even try, that they cannot be trusted, and that their own charter calls for the destruction of Israel (referring to the old charter that has long since been amended). The same arguments once trotted out against the PLO can all be applied to Hamas. This time, however, the Arab countries, as well as the Palestinian Authority, often join the chorus of those who oppose Hamas and refuse to negotiate with them.
Those interested in lasting peace, however, cannot take such a posture. We must be willing to talk to all, seeking the common humanity and goodwill in every corner. It is far too easy to demonize our enemies and those with whom we disagree. Jesus got into trouble for his willingness to associate with sinners, tax collectors, Samaritans, gentiles, and even women. Can his followers dare to follow his example?
It is easy enough to demonize our opponents and associate only with our friends and those who agree with us. It takes great courage and patience to open ourselves to those with whom we disagree, whether it is the Jewish settlers, right wing (or left wing) extremists, Zionist extremists, religious fanatics, or anyone else who disagrees with us. Yet, this is precisely what we need to do.
I understand that this challenge may be a bridge too far for some of you. After all, it runs against the conventional wisdom of most activist organizations and individuals. It also may be against the law. But, I would like to hear from others who disagree with me. At least, let us have a conversation about a topic that has been a taboo for too long.
“You have heard that it was said, “You must love your neighbor and hate your enemy.” But I say to you, love your enemies and pray for those who harass you so that you will be acting as children of your Father who is in heaven. He makes the sun rise on both the evil and the good and sends rain on both the righteous and the unrighteous. If you love only those who love you, what reward do you have? Don’t even the tax collectors do the same? And if you greet only your brothers and sisters, what more are you doing? Don’t even the Gentiles do the same? Therefore, just as your heavenly Father is complete in showing love to everyone, so also you must be complete.
—Matthew 5:43-48 (CEB)
Take Action!
Demand Action!
Stop the Ethnic Cleansing in Masafer Yatta
(United Methodist Kairos Response-UMKR) In early May, the Israeli High Court approved the forced eviction of a collection of Palestinian communities in the Masafer Yatta area, in the south of the West Bank. In effect, the court approved a war crime. It will be the largest forcible transfer of Palestinians from their land since 1967. These expulsions and demolitions can happen at any time, with no notice. Indeed, they have begun already! Demolitions and horrific displacement are underway now. We know that over 1,200 Palestinians, including 500 children, are threatened with the destruction of their homes and communities. Demand Action!
Demand Action!
Heartbreaking Illegal Decision — Contact Congress Now to Free Ahmad
(Rebuilding Alliance) Ahmad Manasra is being held in a prison hospital due to deteriorating mental health, following seven months of solitary confinement. Your action is key. Though Ahmad was a child of 13 when arrested in 2015, the court delayed his trial until he was 14 to intentionally try him as an adult. On June 22, the Special Release Committee decided to continue to illegally apply a law that did not exist at the time of his arrest to continue holding him as an adult. On Tuesday, June 28th the Special Release Committee will reevaluate the possibility for his release because of his health condition. Your action as a constituent is needed today, by Monday noon. Congress may be the only ones who can intervene—but only when constituents ask.
Get Involved!
FOSNA invites you to join us in the following events and activities:
July 13
Theology, Liberation, & Palestine: Honoring the Life & Work of Rosemary Radford Ruether
Join FOSNA for a webinar conversation on the past, present, and future of liberation theology in the context of Palestine/Israel, in dialogue with and honor of the life and work of Rosemary Radford Ruether. On top of being one of the most important theologians of recent memory, Rosemary was a a dear friend and deeply important to FOSNA and the global Sabeel movement as a whole. Speakers include: Naim Ateek, Marc Ellis, Nora Carmi, Kathy Bergen, and more.
Stay tuned!
Regional Affiliate Highlight
Speaking of Palestine Radio Show
Speaking of Palestine is a radio show hosted by members of California’s North Coast Coalition for Palestine, a partner of NorCal Sabeel. The show is broadcast on the nation’s first bilingual public radio station, KBBF, 89.1 FM, and are also available online. New episodes air from 4 to 5 p.m. on the first and third Monday of each month. The latest episode features an interview with AFSC's Dov Baum, discussing the recent divestment victory with General Mills/Pillsbury. We highly recommend you check it out.
Weekly
Sabeel Prayer Service. Join Sabeel every Thursday (6pm Jerusalem) for online Bible Study, discussion, and prayer. Examine scripture in light of the ongoing realities confronting the Palestinian Church and the pursuit of Palestinian liberation.
Wave of Prayer. Subscribe to receive Sabeel's Wave of Prayer, enabling friends of Sabeel around the world to pray over issues of critical concern to the Holy Land on a weekly basis.
Kumi Now! (Week 25) Palestinian Refugees. Palestinians who were either forced from or fled their homes in 1948 and 1967 hoped for a quick return to their houses and land. Few would have foreseen that, decades later, they and their descendants would be living as refugees or internally displaced Palestinians. In 2019 UNRWA reported that over 5.4 million Palestinian refugees were registered with its offices in the five geographic areas where it works: Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, and Gaza. There are 58 refugee camps in the region: 10 in Jordan, 12 in Lebanon, 9 in Syria, 19 in the West Bank, and 8 in the Gaza Strip. 28.4% of all registered refugees continue to live in camps, with the highest percentage in Lebanon with 50.6%, followed by Gaza with 40.9%. The Palestinian refugee issue remains as intractable as ever and no permanent peace solution between Israel and the Palestinians can take place without either ensuring the rights of Palestinian refugees to return or providing restitution.
