Broken Paradigms
by Jonathan Kuttab
The events of the last few days in Israel and Gaza have shattered the long-held assumptions of many observers, working to shift many popular paradigms. Amidst the devastation, there does remain reason to hope that these events will shake up the status quo and lead to major changes. Even the taking of captives could serve as a catalyst for the opening of negotiations and contacts between Hamas and Israel. The astonishing and unexpected military success of Hamas in breaching the separation wall and in shifting the battle over the weekend to the enemy’s population could potentially even help reduce the power imbalance and lead to genuine talks.
For one thing, the fighting mostly took place inside sovereign Israeli territory and amongst its civilian population. This has never happened since the creation of the state in 1948, whereby the Israeli army successfully ensured that for all the wars with the Arab World the fighting (and the vast majority of destruction, civilian casualties, and human suffering) occurred within Arab territories and amongst the Arab population. It was Israeli soldiers who entered Arab houses, ordered kids out of their beds, kidnapped them and took them in their jeeps, controlled their lives, and triumphantly returned to their own homes at the end of hostilities.
My heart goes out to the families who lost their dear ones and particularly to those who still do not know the fate of their loved ones, who may be dead, injured, or held captive under the power and mercy of their enemies.
While watching Israeli TV in Hebrew (simultaneously with Palestinian sources in Arabic) I heard the stories of Israeli families who lived in fear under lockdown, without electricity, and who attempted to call for help but no responsible agency would answer or come to their rescue. It seems, those Israelis living a few kilometers from Gaza were given, for a few days, a taste of what Gazans experience all year round.
I mention this not to provide any excuse or justification for the actions of armed elements or to compare the personal sufferings of Palestinians in Gaza with those of Israeli civilians. Nor do I wish to decontextualize these events from a decades long history of Palestinian dispossession at the hands of Israel. My point is that war, occupation, and violence are awful, and the suffering of civilians is inexcusable. It is vital that each party comes to understand and begin to empathize with the other, work to put an end to this awful situation, and seek an authentic peace built upon a foundation of justice, one that all deserve.
Unfortunately, the emphasis instead has been to double down on the assertion of power and violence, seeking ways to maximize the suffering of the other in order to achieve “victory.” This is true for Palestinians, the weaker party, who tasted for the first time a small measure of victory, even as they realize what a heavy price they will be made to pay for it. Among them, the psychological high of their astonishing accomplishment in breaching the impenetrable wall and wreaking havoc on their vastly superior tormentors is intoxicating, and much more appealing than the call for principled nonviolent struggle. It is also true for the Israelis, who are openly flouting any restraints of morality, international law, proportionality, or public opinion as they bring their vastly superior force to pummel the Gaza strip, cutting off entirely their water, fuel, food, electricity, and destroying their boats, mosques, buildings, this time without even bothering to warn populated residential areas. They still believe they can “bring Hamas to its knees” through sheer military might and bend them to their will.
Against this tsunami of blood lust, I raise my voice in calling for a just peace. It’s at times like these when we need to remember Jesus’ teaching to “love thy neighbor as thyself.” The prince of peace calls us, against our natural impulses to hate, fight, and kill our enemies, instead to understand, empathize with, and, yes, even love them.
This is not an empty hope. This week’s events do break an unsustainable status quo, challenging everyone to think beyond the current paradigms. They challenge a status quo in which Israel felt it was unassailable, that it was unnecessary to even deal with the Palestinians, and that it could achieve normalization with the Arab world without the Palestinians. Also, the existence of a large number of hostages (for all the human suffering involved) means that it is necessary to engage in some form of negotiations to accomplish their release, probably in return for releasing Palestinian prisoners, of whom 1300 are administrative detainees, held without charge or trials, who are often referred to by Palestinians as “kidnapped hostages.” Finally, the absence of any realistic plan to deal with Gaza militarily may convince enough Israelis to deal with it in a different matter.
The truth is that there is no military solution, and once that becomes clear to one and all, perhaps we can finally decide to give peace a chance. Perhaps if we spend at least a little time trying to see things from the perspective of others and show a bit of empathy, we can be closer to a solution, and the effort will certainly be rewarded.
Take Action!
Emergency Relief
United Palestine Appeal is collecting emergency relief for Palestinians in Gaza. Please consider donating today to provide life saving aid in a time of suffering through a known, trusted source on the ground.
End Violence and Occupation in Palestine and Israel
(AFSC) Between Oct. 7 and 8, attacks by Palestinians from Gaza in Israel killed at least 700 Israeli citizens and Israeli attacks on Gaza killed at least 500 Palestinians. Prime Minister Netanyahu promised “mighty vengeance” and that Israel's military actions “will continue with neither limitations nor respite.” Gaza has also been placed under comprehensive closure with Israel blocking the import of electricity, water, fuel, food, medicine, and all other goods.
Further military action will accomplish nothing but more death and destruction. Right now, Congress must call for an immediate end to all violence—and to address the apartheid system and persistent inequality that are the root cause of this violence.
Urge Congress to speak out today!
Also, Tell Congress: Don't fuel this devastating violence.
(JVP Action) We cannot stand by while our politicians fuel genocide in Gaza. JVP Action, a sister organization to Jewish Voice for Peace, has developed a tool to move our members of Congress to de-escalate and prevent the further loss of Palestinian and Israeli life.
Get Involved!
We invite you to join us in the following events and activities:
Sabeel Service
Join us this Thursday, October 12th at 11:00am ET / 6:00pm Palestine for a special worship service by Sabeel in response to the recent crisis in the Holy Land. Speakers will include Archbishop Elias Chacour, Archbishop Atallah Hanna, Patriarch Michel Sabbah, Reverend Dr. Naim Ateek, and Bishop Munib Younan.
October 13 - 14: New York & Santa Cruz
Battling the ‘IHRA definition’: Theory & Activism
Join the first convening of the Institute for the Critical Study of Zionism in October 2023! This inaugural gathering will bring together ICSZ’s community of scholars and activists to build and share knowledge about how “the IHRA definition of antisemitism” both amplifies and hides repressive power and state violence.
This is a working meeting for scholars and activists of ICSZ’s community, particularly those engaged in researching and confronting the repressive use of “the IHRA definition” to foreclose critical discussion and scholarship on Zionism. A selection of papers and videos of presentations will, however, be published after the event.
Registering: Please use this form if you’re interested in attending. Due to limitations on attendance, filling out this form does not immediately register you for the convening. You will receive a response as quickly as possible from our volunteer team to confirm the status of your registration. Deadline: October 9.
Weekly
Sabeel Prayer Service. Join Sabeel every Thursday (6pm Palestine) for online Bible Study, discussion, and prayer. Examine scripture in light of the ongoing realities confronting the Palestinian Church and the pursuit of Palestinian liberation.
Wave of Prayer. Subscribe to receive Sabeel's Wave of Prayer, enabling friends of Sabeel around the world to pray over issues of critical concern to the Holy Land on a weekly basis.
Kumi Now! October 15 to 21: Week 42 - Profiting from Occupation
Kumi Now is an online gathering every Tuesday (6pm Palestine) with a guest speaking on the weekly topic. Register here.
Every week, hundreds of companies and corporations are profiting off the occupation. Sadly, these profits are at the cost of the rights and livelihoods of the Palestinian people. On October 21, 2003 the United Nations condemned the Israeli Apartheid Wall, demanding “that Israel stop and reverse the construction of the wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory.” Building of that wall continues, and it is just one way that outside corporations are directly profiting off the occupation, aiding in its construction and flocking to the industrial zones and settlements it enables. Here’s what you need to know about corporations profiting off the occupation and what you can do so that together we can rise up.